Epicranial Cortical Stimulation using Simpleware Software

Human head model with ECS electrode, and multi-part volume mesh of the model

Overview

Epicranial cortical stimulation (ECS) is a novel neuromodulation technique that has the advantage of delivering strong electric field to the brain in a minimally invasive manner. To show the potential, computational modeling becomes necessary in order to evaluate electric fields within soft tissue. For this purpose, researchers at KU Leuven used Simpleware software to create a model of a real human head implanted with ECS electrodes and to generate tetrahedral meshes, which were exported to an external simulation software (COMSOL Multiphysics®). An important feature in Simpleware software is the ability to generate high-quality meshes with high density at the region of interest (ROI) which could produce accurate results in a cost-effective way. The results from this work were published in Frontiers in Neuroscience.

Highlights

  • Epicranial cortical stimulation is believed to induce strong electric fields in the brain
  • A real human head with implanted ECS electrodes were modeled using Simpleware ScanIP
  • Using Simpleware FE, tetrahedral meshes with high density at the ROI were generated 
  • Meshes were exported to COMSOL Multiphysics®
  • Results show that ECS can deliver strong field to the brain

Thanks to

Ahmad Khatoun, Boateng Asamoah and Myles Mc Laughlin, Department of Neurosciences, KU Leuven

 

Reference

Khatoun, A., Asamoah, B., Mc Laughlin, M., 2018. Investigating the Feasibility of Epicranial Cortical Stimulation Using Concentric-Ring Electrodes: A Novel Minimally Invasive Neuromodulation Method. Frontiers in Neuroscience. 13, 773.

Introduction

Cortical stimulation techniques have been shown as being effective for treating different pathological and psychiatric techniques, including both invasive and non-invasive methods. In terms of the former, direct cortical stimulation (DCS) requires a craniotomy to place electrodes directly over the brain. DCS produces strong neuromodulation effects, but at a higher risk to the patient. By contrast, transcranial electric stimulation (tES) is a non-invasive neuromodulation technique that passes a safer but weaker electric current between electrodes attached to the scalp.

Researchers at KU Leuven have developed a novel minimally invasive neuromodulation technique, epicranial cortical stimulation (ECS) to increase treatment effectiveness by placing the stimulating electrodes under the skin and directly on the skull. This research looked into ECS’s potential to deliver strong electric fields to the brain and used computational modeling to estimate the induced cortical electric field during ECS compared to tES and DCS. To do so, Simpleware software was used to generate a high-quality model of the human head with desired electrodes, which was then exported to COMSOL Multiphysics for simulating electric field distribution.

Human Head Modeling

To generate the human head model, the detailed model MIDA (Iacono et al., 2015) was imported to Simpleware ScanIP. This model consists of 115 surface meshes representing different tissues being segmented from head scans. Using the Simpleware CAD module, the surface meshes were transformed into image-based masks and then merged to form the main five masks of interest: Skin, skull, cerebrospinal fluid, grey matter, white matter and air (see Fig.1). The masks showed some inconsistencies between the imported surfaces such as gaps, which appear as empty voxels between two adjacent masks representing tissue. These imperfections are unrealistic and can affect the mesh generation. To correct for this, holes were filled using the image processing tools in Simpleware ScanIP.

Human head model sagittal view taken using Simpleware ScanIP

Figure 1. A screen shot of the human head model sagittal view (taken using Simpleware ScanIP) showing the distinct segmented tissues in different colors: skin (orange), skull (pale yellow), cerebrospinal fluid (blue), grey matter (dark grey), white matter (light grey) and air (black)

Electrodes Modeling

The ECS electrode consisted of a central disk and ring electrodes with an insulating back layer to prevent current from passing through the skin. The electrode layer was first modeled by dilating a copy of the skin mask using the Simpleware 3D editing tool, and then applying the Boolean operation tool to keep the part of the mask intersecting with skin. 

After generating the electrode layer, a new cylindrical mask was generated with the desired radius, orientation and location and defined the intersection with the electrode layer as the central disk electrode. Similarly, the ring electrodes were created by subtracting two disk electrodes with radii representing the inner and the outer edges of the ring. To model the insulating back layer, a similar approach for generating the electrodes was employed where it was ensured that the layers cover all the electrodes to prevent direct contact with the skin (see Fig.2).

Human head model in Simpleware ScanIP after electrode implantation

Figure 2: The human head model after electrode implantation. Left: sagittal view (taken using Simpleware ScanIP) showing the central disk and the ring electrode in red and the insulating layer in green. Right: screenshot from the 3D view in Simpleware ScanIP. The opacity of the skin and the insulating layer is set low to better illustrate the electrode over the skull

Tetrahedral Mesh Generation

After building the model of the human head and the electrode, the Simpleware FE module was used to generate the tetrahedral meshes (see Fig. 3). To achieve more accurate results, the number of elements of the tetrahedral meshes in the area surrounding the electrodes was increased. This very useful function improves the accuracy of the model results while maintaining reasonable data quantity and simulation time.

Multi-part volume mesh of the human head using the Simpleware FE module

Figure 3: Multi-part volume mesh of the human head, including: white matter, grey matter, CSF, skull, electrode components, soft tissues, and air, generated using Simpleware FE, for simulation in COMSOL Multiphysics©

Simulation & Results

The tetrahedral meshes were imported to COMSOL Multiphysics where the boundary conditions were set, and the electric field was estimated by solving the Laplace equation. The results showed that the electric field generated during ECS can be more than 20 times stronger than that generated during tES (see Fig. 4). The results also showed that the strength and the focality of the induced cortical electric field is dependent on the electrode size and the distance between the central and the ring electrodes.

Simulation of electric field distribution during ECS in COMSOL Multiphysics©

Figure 4: Simulation results from COMSOL showing the electric field distribution during ECS (left) and tES (right) when the same 1 mA current was applied. (Note scale bar limits) The results show a stronger and more focused electric field during ECS to that of tES

Conclusions

Epicranial cortical stimulation (ECS) is a novel minimally invasive neuromodulation technique that can deliver strong cortical electric field. This was shown using a computational model that was generated using Simpleware software and COMSOL Multiphysics. Such techniques can be used to stimulate different cortical regions and to treat a number of neurological and psychological diseases. The study’s results showed that the electrode configuration affects the electric field strength and focality in the brain. In order to achieve optimal therapeutic effects while avoiding unwanted side effects, future computational studies should focus on optimizing the electrode design in order to target a specific cortical region while avoiding the stimulation of other parts.

Any Questions?

Do you have any questions about this case study or how to use Simpleware software for your own workflows?